发新话题
打印

求助!!一道逻辑题!!

求助!!一道逻辑题!!

Any person who drops out of high school will be unemployed unless he or she finds a low-paying job or has relatives with good business connections.

Which one of the following conclusions CANNOT be validly drawn from the statement above?

A.  Any person who drops out of high school, will be unemployed, have a low-paying job, or have relatives with good business connections.

B.  Any high school dropout who has neither a low-paying job nor relatives with good business connections will be unemployed.

C   Any employed person who has neither a low -paying job nor relatives with good business connectoins is not a high school dropout.

D.   Any high school dropout who has a job that is not low-paying must have relatives with good business connections.

E. Any person who has relatives with good business connections and who is not a high school dropout must be employed at a job that is not low - paying.

答案为什么是E ??
原命题:
从高校辍学的学生有工作---〉1.他门找了一份低收入的工作,Or 2.他们有好的商业关系
A选项不明白是怎么推的,和原命题有什么关系?
B选项为原命题的逆否命题所以可以从原命题中推出(排除)
C选项同B选项为你否命题(排除)
D选项,从高校辍学的学生有工作——〉2.他们有好的商业关系  为原命题的重述,所以排除。
E选项不明白是怎么推的 ?

求助!!!!!!!!!!
谢谢!!!!!

TOP

首先,A 标点错了。will 前面那个逗号要删除。

题干说的是除非有关系,否则高中(注意,是高中,不是高校)缀学的不是失业就是做低薪工作。这并不是说有关系的就一定不失业或是不做低薪工作。所以 E 不正确。(If not P then not Q 并不等于 If P then Q。)

A 的意思就是说没有在高中毕业的学生只有三个可能:失业,做低薪工作,有关系。这正是题干所说的。

TOP

Many thanks

明白了!!!!  太感谢了!! Many thanks!!!

TOP

发新话题